"What Happens if We Leave Afghanistan" asks TIME and it poses the question with a cover that's as controversial as it is disturbing. The image is of an 18-year-old Afghan woman whose nose has been cut off. According to TIME, the woman "was sentenced by a Taliban commander to have her nose and ears cut off for fleeing her abusive in-laws." Her story, says the newsweekly, represents what will happen in Afghanistan if the US military ends its mission, now in its eighth year.
Pro: Meenal Vamburkar at Mediaite: "This reasoning follows what many might agree is the definition and purpose of good journalism. The things that are hard to look at are often the things that are most necessary to look at. Whether readers think the cover is bold or too graphic, the shock value cannot be denied."
Contra: Choire Sicha at the Awl: "That sure sounds like an argument -- and, you know, a very moving and affecting one! -- for something like a permanent or at least extended occupation."
It is no accident that this particular TIME cover appears in the week when WikiLeaks led the news cycle with its publication of US military intelligence documents. The secretive website, which claims the right to publish secret information, may have put hundreds of Afghan informants in danger by its actions and it might be salutatory for its fans to study this graphic reminder of how truly barbaric the Taliban really is. This movement will stop at nothing to achieve its wicked aims and should these require the mutilation of defenceless women, then the Taliban will cut off their noses and ears.